4.9 KiB
The problems with overwriting keys
Branches for some of that stuff exist to archive it instead of loosing it forever.
Initial target You write a symbols file based on your specified mapping, and that's pretty much it. There were two mappings: The first one is in the keycodes file and contains "<10> = 10", which is super redundant but needed for xkb. The second one mapped "<10>" to characters, modifiers, etc. using symbol files in xkb. However, if you had one keyboard layout for your mouse that writes SHIFT keys on keycode 10, and one for your keyboard that is normal and writes 1/! on keycode 10, then you would not be able to write ! by pressing that mouse button and that keyboard button at the same time. Keycodes may not clash.
This was quite mature, pretty much finished.
The second idea was to write special keycodes known only to key-mapper (256 - 511) into the input device of your mouse in /dev/input, and map those to SHIFT and such, whenever a button is clicked. A mapping would have existed to prevent the original keycode 10 from writing a 1. But X/Linux seem to ignore anything greater than 255 for regular keyboard events, or even crash in some cases. Mouse click buttons can use those high keycodes though, but they cannot be remapped.
The third idea is to create a new input device that uses 8 - 255, just like other layouts, and key-mapper always tries to use the same keycodes for SHIFT as already used in the system default. The pipeline is like this:
- A human thumb presses an extra-button of the device "mouse"
- key-mapper uses evdev to get the event from "mouse", sees "ahh, it's a 10, I know that one and will now write 50 into my own device". 50 is the keycode for SHIFT on my regular keyboard, so it won't clash anymore with alphanumeric keys and such.
- X has key-mappers configs for the key-mapper device loaded and checks in it's keycodes config file "50, that would be <50>", then looks into it's symbols config "<50> is mapped to SHIFT", and then it actually presses the SHIFT down to modify all other future buttons.
- X has another config for "mouse" loaded, which prevents any system default mapping to print the overwritten key "1" into the session.
But this is a rather complicated approach. The mapping of 10 -> 50 would have to be stored somewhere as well. It would make the mess of configuration files already needed for xkb even worse. This idea was not considered for long, so no "third" branch exists.
Fourth idea: Based on the first idea, instead of using keycodes greater than 255, use unused keycodes starting from 255, going down. Issues existed when two buttons with the same keycode are pressed at the same time, so the goal is to avoid such overlaps. For example, if keycode 10 should be mapped to Shift_L. It is impossible to write "!" using this mapped button and a second keyboard, except if pressing key 10 triggers key-mapper to write key 253 into the /dev device, while mapping key 10 to nothing. Unfortunately linux just completely ignores some keycodes. 140 works, 145 won't, 150 works.
Fifth idea: Instead of writing xkb symbol files, just disable all mouse buttons with a single symbol file. Key-mapper listens for key events in /dev and then writes the mapped keycode into a new device in /dev. For example, if 10 should be mapped to Shift_L, xkb configs would disable key 10 and key-mapper would write 50 into /dev, which is Shift_L in xmodmaps output. This sounds incredibly simple and makes me throw away tons of code.
How I would have liked it to be
setxkbmap -layout ~/.config/key-mapper/mouse -device 13
config looks like:
10 = a, A
11 = Shift_L
done. Without crashing X. Without printing generic useless errors. Without colliding with other devices using the same keycodes. If it was that easy, an app to map keys would have already existed.
Folder Structure of Key Mapper in /usr
Stuff has to be placed in /usr/share/X11/xkb to my knowledge.
Every user gets a path within that /usr/... directory which is very
unconventional, but it works. This way the presets of multiple users
don't clash.
Presets
/usr/share/X11/xkb/symbols/key-mapper/<user>/<device>/<preset>
This is how a single preset is stored.
Defaults
/usr/share/X11/xkb/symbols/key-mapper/<user>/default
This is where key-mapper stores the defaults. They are generated from the
parsed output of xmodmap and used to keep the unmapped keys at their system
defaults.
Keycodes
/usr/share/X11/xkb/keycodes/key-mapper
Because the concept of "reasonable symbolic names" (www.x.org) doesn't apply when mouse buttons are all over the place, an identity mapping to make generating "symbols" files easier/possible exists. A keycode of 10 will be known as "<10>" in symbols configs. This has the added benefit that keycodes reported by xev can be identified in the symbols file.