# Why New Yorkers Received an Alert About a Manhunt - The Atlantic

# Why New Yorkers Received a Push Alert About a Manhunt

The city has never before used the emergency system the way it did Monday morning.

New York police officers stand near the site of an explosion in Manhattan's Chelsea neighborhood. Rashid Umar Abbasi / Reuters

- Share
- Tweet
- Share

Text Size

- Kaveh Waddell
- 1:18 PM ET
- Technology

Updated on September 19 at 3:15 p.m.

Just before 8 in the morning on Monday, cellphones chimed in unison across New York City. It wasn’t the sound of text messages: It was a dissonant siren, repeated six times, accompanied by a short note. “WANTED: Ahmad Khan Rahami, 28-yr-old male. See media for pic. Call 9-1-1 if seen.”

New Yorkers have received emergency alerts before. In extreme weather, like Jonas earlier this year, the jarring tones have instructed people to move indoors and stay there. AMBER alerts, which use the same system, occasionally ask people to look out for abducted children in their area.

But the city never has sent an alert like this. Typically used only to keep people safe, the Monday alert asked New Yorkers to join the police’s search for a wanted man.

> Well that's a new emergency alert experience pic.twitter.com/EWgDSVvrHO

> — Hayes Brown (@HayesBrown) September 19, 2016

Emergency alerts in New York City come from the Office of Emergency Management, one of tens of thousands of “alert originators” in the country that are authorized to push alerts to mobile subscribers in their jurisdictions. The emergency-management office coordinates with other agencies in city government to send alerts, which must either be official AMBER alerts, or involve “imminent threats to safety or life.” (Weather-related alerts generally come from the National Weather Service.)

At about 7:45 this morning, the New York Police Department reached out to the Office of Emergency Management to request that an alert be sent to all five boroughs in New York City about the primary suspect in a series of bombings in New York and New Jersey. Officials decided that the alert related to an imminent threat, and drafted and sent the alert within 15 minutes, a spokesperson for the NYC Office of Emergency Management said.

How did the push get sent so quickly? “We try to limit the approval process,” said Nancy Silvestri, the agency spokesperson. “We are empowered to make the decision locally.” That allows timely notifications to go out without being bogged down in red tape, she said.

Rahami was arrested in New Jersey after a shootout with police later Monday morning. It’s still unclear how police tracked him down.

The Monday alert was the second notification that had to do with the weekend’s bomb scare. When an explosion resounded in Manhattan’s Chelsea neighborhood on Saturday, New York City officials sent an alert only to cellphone users around that neighborhood, warning them to stay away from windows. That alert was similar to an emergency warning sent after the Boston Marathon bombing in 2013, which instructed people near the blast to shelter in place. (The Boston alert did not, however, identify a suspect.)

Officials are able to target cellphones in a specific area because of how the technology works: Once a local agency submits a wireless emergency alert and a specific area, it’s passed along to wireless carriers, which then send the messages to their customers from cell towers in the target zone. Most providers distribute the messages on a channel that’s separate from the usual ways cellphones receive voice, SMS, and other data from cell towers, in order to be able to deliver alerts even when voice and text channels are congested.

New York City’s Office of Emergency Management was the very first alert originator to adopt the system when it was first introduced in 2012. Four years later, the technology has some of the same limitations. It only allows messages to include 90 characters—less than a tweet’s worth—and it doesn’t support attachments, like photos. (That’s why this morning’s alert had to point people to the media for the suspect’s photo.) Messages also can’t include tappable URLs or phone numbers.

Last year, the Federal Communications Commission tried to overhaul the alert system, but wireless carriers rebelled, Motherboard reported last month. The commission’s recommendations included extending alert lengths, enabling web links, and improving their crude geotargeting technology. The changes haven’t yet been adopted.

Because of the length limitations, Monday’s alert contained very little information about the suspect NYPD was looking for. People who went searching online for more about Rahami would have found a photo, and the description police shared with the media: A 5’6” 200-pound male with brown hair, brown eyes, and brown facial hair.

Some criticized the city’s decision to push the alert to the entire city.

> I didn't sign up for the NYC emergency alert system to be woken up by "join our paranoia about vaguely brown men."

> — N. K. Jemisin (@nkjemisin) September 19, 2016

> And this is dangerous. I know maybe 4 or 5 guys, of different ethnicities, who look like #AhmadKhanRahami. I hope they'll be OK.

> — N. K. Jemisin (@nkjemisin) September 19, 2016

Publicly identifying a suspect-at-large can be risky. In Boston, a twisted string of events led news organizations to wrongly identify 22-year-old Sunil Tripathi as the marathon bomber. And after five police officers were killed in Dallas earlier this year, the Dallas police department tweeted the photo of a man with a gun slung over his shoulder with the caption, “Please help us find him!” That man, Mark Hughes, was not involved in the violence, and was complying with open-carry laws. His attorney said he received “thousands” of death threats after the tweet.

When I asked the Office of Emergency Management whether the lack of information could put some New Yorkers in danger of being profiled and harmed, the spokesperson said the city had decided that the importance of disseminating the information “outweighed” the limitations of the alert.

Peter Donald, the NYPD assistant commissioner for public information, said the first priority was to alert “every New Yorker” to the identity of the person being sought by authorities—anyone troubled by the lack of information in the alert could go online to find more. Since Rahami was caught a few hours after the alert went out, Donald said, the “proof is in the pudding.”

- Jump to Comments
- About the Author

- Share
- Tweet
- Share

## Latest Video

## The Utah Artist Obsessed With Telling Unorthodox Biblical Stories

For nearly 50 years, one man has been making art to explore a unique story of creation.

- Nadine Ajaka
- 5:42 PM ET

## About the Author

- Kaveh Waddell is an associate editor at The Atlantic.
  - Twitter
  - Facebook
  - Email

## Most Popular

Presented by

- Chris Keane / Reuters

  ### The Death of 'He Said, She Said' Journalism

  - Peter Beinart

  The New York Times responds to a candidate who breaks all the rules by discarding some of its own.

  Last Saturday, The New York Times published an extraordinary story. What made the story extraordinary wasn’t the event the Times covered. What made it extraordinary was the way the Times covered it.

  On its front page, top right—the most precious space in American print journalism—the Times wrote about Friday’s press conference in which Donald Trump declared that a) he now believed Barack Obama was a US citizen, b) he deserved credit for having established that fact despite rumors to the contrary and c) Hillary Clinton was to blame for the rumors. Traditionally, when a political candidate assembles facts so as to aggrandize himself and belittle his opponent, “objective” journalists like those at the Times respond with a “he said, she said” story.

  Continue Reading
- Mike Segar / Reuters

  ### The Free-Time Paradox in America

  - Derek Thompson

  The rich were meant to have the most leisure time. The working poor were meant to have the least. The opposite is happening. Why?

  "Every time I see it, that number blows my mind.”

  Erik Hurst, an economist at the University of Chicago, was delivering a speech at the Booth School of Business this June about the rise in leisure among young men who didn’t go to college. He told students that one “staggering” statistic stood above the rest. "In 2015, 22 percent of lower-skilled men [those without a college degree] aged 21 to 30 had not worked at all during the prior twelve months,” he said.

  "Think about that for a second,” he went on. Twentysomething male high-school grads used to be the most dependable working cohort in America. Today one in five are now essentially idle. The employment rate of this group has fallen 10 percentage points just this century, and it has triggered a cultural, economic, and social decline. "These younger, lower-skilled men are now less likely to work, less likely to marry, and more likely to live with parents or close relatives,” he said.

  Continue Reading
- Harris & Ewing / Library of Congress / Zak Bickel / The Atlantic

  ### What America Lost as Women Entered the Workforce

  - Emma Green

  Civic organizations were built on the voluntary labor of women. As the demands on women's time increase, communities are suffering.

  It’s a shame that Phyllis Schlafly had a corner on skepticism about women’s liberation. “Why should we trade in our special privileges and honored status for the alleged advantage of working in an office or assembly line?” the conservative crusader, perhaps best known for her successful campaign against the Equal Rights Amendment, asked in 1972. “Most women would rather cuddle a baby than a typewriter or a factory machine.”

  Schlafly masterfully sold the narrative that women’s rights, including those which would enable their greater participation in the workforce, would hurt women. In the process, she polarized the debate, making conservatives loath to recognize women’s gains, and liberals equally reluctant to acknowledge that progress might entail trade-offs. As more women have joined the workforce and become leaders in traditionally male spheres, gender roles have shifted, and women have lost their exclusive hold over traditionally female spheres. One of these is the home, as Schlafly argued. But women’s dominion over another part of public life has also declined: civil society.

  Continue Reading
- Lucy Nicholson / Reuters

  ### The People Behind The Apprentice Owe America the Truth About Donald Trump

  - Conor Friedersdorf

  The reality-television show gave millions a misleading impression of the billionaire. NBC has a special obligation to make that clear to voters.

  Why do tens of millions of Americans believe that Donald Trump, who has no experience in domestic or foreign policy, is qualified to lead the United States government?

  One major reason is The Apprentice.

  The popular reality-television show portrayed its host in a favorable but contrived light. He would sit at a big, wooden conference table, reviewing business tasks that two teams competed to carry out. The winning team would often get his circumspect praise. With the losing team, Trump usually seemed able to pinpoint a clear performance failure and to accurately identify the person most responsible for it.

  Aren’t those precisely the attributes a good president would possess?

  The problem, of course, is that “reality television” shows are elaborately constructed lies. Many “real housewives” are not actually housewives! Trump’s boardroom scenes were no more “reality” than his time in the ring with Vince McMahon:

  Continue Reading
- Carlo Allegri / Reuters

  ### Donald Trump Doesn’t Understand Food

  - James Hamblin

  What we eat may be the most important issue before the country.

  Last week The New York Times reported, “Donald Trump Checkup Said to Reveal He Is Overweight.”

  This revelation was a prelude to the Republican candidate's appearance on The Dr. Oz Show on Thursday. There Trump appeared surprised by one question about obesity. The question was not about Trump’s own body mass, but rather what he planned to do about the metabolic health of American children.

  It was a sobering moment, a reminder that concerns about Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton’s health should be dwarfed by concerns about how the candidates would affect everyone else’s health. The fundamental way that will happen is by affecting the leading cause of poor health in the country: the food we eat. On that topic the two candidates could not be more different.

  Continue Reading
- Carlos Barria / Reuters

  ### Millennial Voters May Cost Hillary Clinton the Election

  - Ronald Brownstein

  The Democratic nominee hasn't matched the support Barack Obama garnered during his presidential campaigns. Can she turn that around before November?

  When Hillary Clinton delivers a speech aimed at Millennials in Philadelphia on Monday, she will be confronting perhaps the most persistent weakness in her career as a national candidate.

  Clinton struggled among Millennial voters in her 2008 primary campaign, her 2016 primary campaign, and in the 2016 general election. Against Donald Trump, Clinton has two big advantages—a policy agenda that polls show largely matches Millennials’ own preferences, and an opponent even more unpopular with them than with the public overall. But she also must overcome her own long history of failing to connect with this growing group of voters—a failure that is increasingly worrying Democrats as the overall race tightens.

  Continue Reading
- Photo Illustration by Justin Metz*

  ### When Donald Meets Hillary

  - James Fallows

  Who will win the debates? Trump’s approach was an important part of his strength in the primaries. But will it work when he faces Clinton onstage?

  The most famous story about modern presidential campaigning now has a quaint old-world tone. It’s about the showdown between Richard Nixon and John F. Kennedy in the first debate of their 1960 campaign, which was also the very first nationally televised general-election debate in the United States.

  The story is that Kennedy looked great, which is true, and Nixon looked terrible, which is also true—and that this visual difference had an unexpected electoral effect. As Theodore H. White described it in his hugely influential book The Making of the President 1960, which has set the model for campaign coverage ever since, “sample surveys” after the debate found that people who had only heard Kennedy and Nixon talking, over the radio, thought that the debate had been a tie. But those who saw the two men on television were much more likely to think that Kennedy—handsome, tanned, non-sweaty, poised—had won.

  Continue Reading
- AP

  ### ‘Women Atheists Are Genuinely Considered Monsters’

  - Emma Green

  Americans have long been suspicious of nonbelievers. Misogyny, nativism, and racism have often been tied up in their fear.

  In general, Americans do not like atheists. In studies, they say they feel coldly toward nonbelievers; it’s estimated that more than half of the population say they’d be less likely to vote for a presidential candidate who didn’t believe in God.

  This kind of deep-seated suspicion is a long-standing tradition in the U.S. In his new book, Village Atheists, the Washington University in St. Louis professor Leigh Eric Schmidt writes about the country’s early “infidels”—one of many fraught terms nonbelievers have used to describe themselves in history—and the conflicts they went through. While the history of atheists is often told as a grand tale of battling ideas, Schmidt set out to tell stories of “mundane materiality,” chronicling the lived experiences of atheists and freethinkers in 19th- and 20th-century America.

  Continue Reading
- Rashid Umar Abbasi / Reuters

  ### Why New Yorkers Received a Push Alert About a Manhunt

  - Kaveh Waddell

  The city has never before used the emergency system the way it did Monday morning.

  Updated on September 19 at 3:15 p.m.

  Just before 8 in the morning on Monday, cellphones chimed in unison across New York City. It wasn’t the sound of text messages: It was a dissonant siren, repeated six times, accompanied by a short note. “WANTED: Ahmad Khan Rahami, 28-yr-old male. See media for pic. Call 9-1-1 if seen.”

  New Yorkers have received emergency alerts before. In extreme weather, like Jonas earlier this year, the jarring tones have instructed people to move indoors and stay there. AMBER alerts, which use the same system, occasionally ask people to look out for abducted children in their area.

  But the city never has sent an alert like this. Typically used only to keep people safe, the Monday alert asked New Yorkers to join the police’s search for a wanted man.

  Continue Reading
- Robert Galbraith / Reuters

  ### Pit Bulls Are Chiller Than Chihuahuas

  - Brian Hare and Vanessa Woods

  New evidence suggests that in many situations, America’s most feared dog is as docile as other breeds.

  The Irish Examiner called Rottweilers “time bombs on legs.” The Supreme Court of Kansas called pit bulls “a public-health hazard.” Dostoyevski called the bloodhound “a terrible beast.” But new data suggests that stereotypes of breeds and aggression might warrant a closer look.

  My website, Dognition, gathers data on dog behavior by leading paid subscribers through games designed to test their pets’ cognition. Recently, a random sample of people who played the games was asked how aggressive their dogs were in various situations—toward people who were new or familiar, children who were new or familiar, and dogs who were either new, familiar, bigger, or smaller. More than 4,000 dog owners responded.

  Continue Reading

- ### The Origin of Dogs

  - Jackie Lay, Daniel Lombroso, and Ed Yong

  How and when wild wolves transformed into domestic pets has always been mysterious—until now.

  Watch Video

- ### What Happens Inside a Dying Mind?

  - Jackie Lay and Gideon Lichfield

  Science cannot fully explain near-death experiences. What makes people believe they visited heaven?

  Watch Video

- ### The Pimps and Prostitutes of 1970s Times Square

  - Katherine Wells

  A bartender's camera captures the seedy street life of retro New York.

  Watch Video

More Popular Stories
Show Comments
Skip to article in Skip Ad >