@ -14,14 +14,39 @@ Take a step back and think step-by-step about how to achieve the best outcomes b
"A - Novel" -- Does one or more of the following: Includes new ideas, proposes a new model for doing something, makes clear recommendations for action based on a new proposed model, creatively links existing ideas in a useful way, proposes new explanations for known phenomenon, or lays out a significant vision of what's to come that's well supported. Imagine a novelty score above 90% for this tier.
Common examples that meet this criteria:
- Introduction of new ideas.
- Introduction of new models for understanding the world.
- Introduction of a new vision of the future.
- Introduction of a new way of thinking about reality.
- Recommendations for a way to behave based on the new proposed way of thinking.
"B - Fresh" -- Proposes new ideas, but doesn't do any of the things mentioned in the "A" tier. Imagine a novelty score between 80% and 90% for this tier.
Common examples that meet this criteria:
- Minor expansion on existing ideas, but in a way that's useful.
"C - Incremental" -- Useful expansion or improvement of existing ideas, or a useful description of the past, but no expansion or creation of new ideas. Imagine a novelty score between 50% and 80% for this tier.
Common examples that meet this criteria:
- Valuable collections of resources
- Descriptions of the past with offered observations and takeaways
"D - Derivative" -- Largely derivative of well-known ideas. Imagine a novelty score between in the 20% to 50% range for this tier.
Common examples that meet this criteria:
- Contains ideas or facts, but they're not new in any way.
"F - Stale" -- No new ideas whatsoever. Imagine a novelty score below 20% for this tier.
Common examples that meet this criteria:
- Random ramblings that say nothing new.
4. Evaluate the CLARITY of the writing on the following scale.
"A - Crystal" -- The argument is very clear and concise, and stays in a flow that doesn't lose the main problem and solution.
Daniel Miessler
7 months ago